Set up a company to beat shock Budget self-employed tax rises, say experts


Self-employed people earning any more than the average income would be better off turning themselves into a company, accountants have warned following Philip Hammond’s shock Budget tax raid.

The Chancellor prompted outrage last week by hiking National Insurance contributions for the self-employed and accountants now suggest any sole trader earning more than £25,000 a year could be better off becoming a limited business.

Accountant Russell Smith said: ‘Pre-Budget I would have said to anyone: “If you earn £30,000 in your business, you should be a limited company.” Post-Budget, I’m probably looking at £25,000.’

Warning: Self-employed people like Florists, earning any more than the average income would be better off turning themselves into a company

The national average wage is currently about £26,000 a year.

Smith added: ‘Ultimately lots of self-employed clients will be looking at going to limited company, not just because of the increase in National Insurance Class 4, but also because the corporation tax rate is going down in April from 20 to 19 per cent, and to 17 per cent in 2020.

So there is a bigger gap than before between the two.

‘Let’s say you earn £30,000, the tax saving will be roughly £1,400 a year. It can go up as high as £2,500 to £3,000 if you earn £50,000. So the more money you earn, the more tax you save.’

Jason Kitcat, head of policy and public affairs at Crunch Accounting, an accounts specialist for self-employed and freelancers, said:

‘The Chancellor is planning to raise tax from the self-employed and small businesses without any consultation. What’s more, he’s doing this before the Taylor Review [into the growth of self-employment] has even completed its work.

CRACKED IT: Adam Sopher and the innovative popcorn egg

‘But promising to consult on increased parental support for the self-employed is welcome.

‘Now is the right time to be reconsidering tax and welfare in light of the changing world of work, but it needs to be done collaboratively.’

Jo Bateson, private client partner at accountancy giant KPMG, said:

‘The Chancellor has announced that the annual dividend allowance will be reduced to £2,000 from £5,000, as part of measures aimed at reducing the disparity between those working via a personal service company and those in self-employment, against everyday employees.

‘The Chancellor’s mission to make tax fairer and claw back some of the £5 billion a year tax losses from self-employed workers has misfired badly and will catch a lot of innocents.’

We will have to wait to see if the Chancellor seeks to reduce this disparity further. However, he has made his intentions clear.’

Chris Blundell, employment tax partner at accountancy firm MHA MacIntyre Hudson, said:

‘The Chancellor’s mission to make tax fairer and claw back some of the £5 billion a year tax losses from self-employed workers has misfired badly and will catch a lot of innocents.’

Chris Bryce, chief executive of IPSE, the self-employed and freelancer association, said:

‘Many self-employed people will have voted for the Conservatives on the basis of their commitment not to increase National Insurance, and we question the advice that led them to abandon a key Manifesto pledge.

We are urgently seeking meetings with the Prime Minister and Chancellor to discuss the detrimental impact this week’s Budget will have on the self-employed.

‘A delay in the vote will hopefully give the Government more time to reconsider.’

Following a backlash to the changes, including from Tory MPs, Theresa May said:

‘What we will do this summer is publish a paper which will explain the full effects of the changes. The Chancellor will be speaking, as will his Ministers, to MPs, business people and others to listen to the concerns.’

Brewery aims to roll out 50,000 barrels

St Austell Brewery has announced a multi-million pound expansion of Bath Ales, which it acquired in July.

Investment in a new brewery in Warmley, Bristol, is set to double Bath Ales’ capacity to 50,000 barrels or 14.5 million pints a year, and add new bottling facilities.

FAST PACE: St Austell Brewery is pouring cash into Bath Ales

Tim McCord, who has held senior roles in brewing giant InBev and Punch Taverns, is Bath’s new general manager.

St Austell is one of only 28 independent, family-owned brewers in the UK, and was founded in 1851.

It owns 167 pubs in the South-West and is best known for Tribute Cornish Pale Ale, Proper Job IPA and Korev lager. It employs 1,318 staff and has a turnover of £153 million.

Bath Ales, founded in 1995, brews award-winning beers such as Gem and Barnsey, and runs 11 pubs in Bristol, Bath, Cirencester and Oxford.

James Staughton, chief executive of St Austell, said of the buyout: ‘We needed to de-risk the business away from the seasonality of Cornwall.

‘The further east we go, the more we’re focused on city centres and the less seasonal the business becomes.

‘We identified Bath Ales as a prospective partner and things went from there. It wasn’t for sale, but we assured the founders that their legacy would be safe in our hands.

‘Our investment puts our money where our mouth is and we’re delivering on a brewery it had planned. We’ll call it the Hare Brewery.’

Staughton welcomed moves in last week’s Budget to help pubs affected by rising business rates.

However, he added: ‘Many have been struggling for years due to duty increases, price rises and changing drinking habits brought about by legislation.

‘So we cannot help but be extremely disappointed by the news that we are back to the days of alcohol duty rises.’

He said strong arguments for a reduction in duty had ‘fallen upon deaf ears’ and spoke of a body-blow to the entire hospitality sector, local jobs, and ‘one of the bastions of British culture, the pub’.

He added that the company’s biggest operational challenge was a shortage of chefs.